Thread:Wiki Discussions/@comment-39024013-20190811011415

I've been thinking about it a lot lately, and I think it could work. If someone wanted their story, fanfiction or poem to be reviewable, they would copy and paste this and put it on the top of their story page:

Rules:

 * 1) You must use the review form.
 * 2) Any direct insult to the author is not allowed.
 * 3) Constructive criticism only.
 * 4) Make your review descriptive, do not say 'it was gud'.
 * 5) Do not make your review a summary of the story, actually give feedback.
 * 6) If the author or a poweruser asks you to take your review down, please obey.
 * 7) Follow the regular fandom rules.
 * 8) No biased criticism.

What The Ratings Mean:
1 Cherry: Pretty good, needs a little work. Many critics.

2 Cherries: Pretty good, a few critics.

3 Cherries: A nearly perfect story, almost no critics.

Someone is allowed to write '1.5 cherries', just as long as it doesn't go over 3 cherries.

Review Form:
Name:

Cherry Rating:

What I Like About It:

What I Dislike About It:

How You Can Improve:

Conclusion:

Reviews: 